In Deal Note® 131, we explained that potential buyers build confidence during due diligence when the information provided consistently corroborates the initial narrative presented in the Confidential Information Memorandum (“CIM”). One of the most convincing confirmations an A&D seller has is a document it didn’t write: its customers’ scorecards. OEMs, primes, and Tier 1s track on-time delivery, quality escapes, and corrective actions. Most CIMs make a claim that the company has strong customer relationships and a reputation for quality, and buyers will often scrutinize that comment until they see proof. Proof is usually simple: three straight years of 98% on-time delivery and a preferred supplier status assigned to the company.
Buyers ask for scorecards early in the due diligence process and compare the scores to the projections that have been provided. Revenue derived from a customer that consistently rates the company highly is far easier to believe will continue. Conversely, revenue tied to a customer that has issued repeated corrective action requests appears vulnerable, particularly if that customer represents a significant concentration of sales (Deal Note® 12). A buyer may lower its projections for that customer or tie part of the purchase price to the company keeping that customer. Often the problem isn’t poor performance but poor records. Scorecards sit in a portal no one checks or in the inbox of someone who left the company. A seller unable to produce a cohesive historical record leaves buyers to assume the worst.
Sellers should begin collecting these scorecards on a consistent cadence enabled by their customers well in advance of going to market. Download all available reports from customer portals and track the trend rather than just the latest score. Where problems keep recurring, fix the root cause and document the fix. A low score from two years ago, followed by a clear corrective action and steady improvement, tells a compelling operational story.
If you have a question about this Deal Note®, or have a topic you would like us to write about, please don’t hesitate to let us know.
Have a great day everyone,
Joseph Lakaj
Analyst